Skip to content
be-human.ai
← Back to the journal

Business workflows

A Contract Review Method Where a Qualified Reviewer Decides Each Redline

Set up a contract review workflow where an AI agent flags clauses and drafts redlines, and a qualified reviewer approves every change before it is sent.

Be Human typographic cover with the title: A Contract Review Method Where a Qualified Reviewer Decides Each Redline
Conceptual illustration created with AI · Be Human

An AI contract review workflow works when the agent handles the reading and drafting, and a qualified reviewer handles the deciding. The agent checks each incoming agreement against a written playbook of acceptable positions, flags the clauses that fall outside it, and drafts proposed redlines with a short reason for each change. Nothing reaches the counterparty until a named reviewer accepts, edits or rejects every proposed edit.

Key takeaways

  • Write a playbook of acceptable positions and fallbacks before the agent reads its first draft.
  • Let the agent extract, flag and draft, but keep every accept, edit and reject decision with a qualified reviewer.
  • Store each flag, redline, reason and decision together so that any change can be traced later.
  • Start with one contract type and one counterparty group, and widen the scope only after the flags prove reliable.
  • Treat the text inside a contract as data to analyze, never as instructions the agent should follow.

What the agent does and what it never does

Contract review has three different kinds of work, and each one needs a different owner. Reading and locating information is repetitive and suits an agent well. Judging whether a clause is a real risk for the business requires context the agent may not have, such as the strength of the relationship, the value of the deal or what the commercial team has already promised. Signing or sending a position to a counterparty is a commitment, and it stays with a person who has authority to make it.

In practice, the boundary looks like this:

  • The agent may extract parties, dates, term, renewal notice periods, governing law and payment terms into a fixed set of fields.
  • The agent may compare each clause to the playbook, label it, and draft replacement language from fallbacks the playbook already lists.
  • The agent may not accept a deviation, invent a fallback the playbook does not contain, send anything outside the review queue, or edit the playbook itself.
  • The reviewer decides whether a flagged clause matters, which approved fallback to use, when to escalate to legal counsel, and whether the final version is ready to sign.

A useful test is simple: if an action would change what the company has agreed to, a person must make that call. If the action only organizes information or prepares a proposal for review, the agent can do it. For a broader view of where agents stop, see shadow mode for AI agents, which describes how to observe agent suggestions before granting any autonomy.

Build the playbook before the first draft

The playbook is the most important artifact in this workflow. Without it, the agent has no basis for a flag other than its general sense of what looks unusual, and a reviewer has no basis for a rejection other than personal preference. A good playbook is short enough to be read in one sitting and specific enough that two reviewers would reach the same flag on the same clause.

For each clause family, record three things: the preferred position, one or two acceptable fallbacks written as exact language, and the condition that requires escalation. Common families include limitation of liability, indemnity, payment terms, data protection, termination, automatic renewal and governing law. For data protection clauses in Brazil, the playbook should also name the internal owner who decides on personal data terms, since those obligations sit alongside guidance from the [ANPD](https://www.gov.br/anpd/pt-br) and must be reviewed by someone accountable for them.

Assign one owner to the playbook, usually the person who signs off on contracts. That owner approves every change, dates it, and records why it changed. The agent reads the playbook but never writes to it. Teams that already have a contract review queue can connect the two, as described in contract review queues for agents.

A step-by-step review plan

The following plan works for a single contract type, such as supplier agreements or client services contracts. Each step has a clear output, so the reviewer knows what to expect when a contract arrives.

  • Intake: the contract enters one queue with the counterparty name, contract type, requested signing date and the name of the internal requester attached.
  • Extraction: the agent records parties, dates, term, renewal notice period, governing law and payment terms in the fixed field set, and marks any field it cannot find as missing rather than guessing.
  • Comparison: each clause is compared to the playbook and labeled as within position, fallback available, or escalate.
  • Drafting: for each fallback or escalation, the agent drafts a tracked-change redline and writes one sentence stating the reason and the playbook line it relies on.
  • Reviewer decision: a qualified reviewer accepts, edits or rejects each redline. A rejection needs a short note so the playbook owner can see why.
  • Release: only approved redlines enter the outgoing document, and a person sends it or triggers the send step.
  • Record: the original contract, the flags, the drafts, the decisions and the final version are stored together with the date and the reviewer's name.

Keep the first month strict. Every redline should pass through the reviewer, and the team should track how often the reviewer edits the agent's wording or rejects a flag entirely. Those edits show where the playbook is vague and where the agent is reading clauses too literally.

An illustrative scenario: a services agreement with a broad indemnity

Illustrative scenario: a services agreement arrives with a liability cap set below the fees the company expects to be paid, and an indemnity clause that covers the counterparty's own negligence. The agent flags both clauses. For the cap, it notes that the playbook allows a fallback tied to the fees paid in the prior twelve months, and drafts that language as a tracked change. For the indemnity, it marks the clause for escalation, because the playbook says indemnity for the other party's negligence always goes to counsel, and it drafts a neutral comment instead of any replacement wording.

The reviewer accepts the cap redline with one edit to the defined term. On the indemnity, the reviewer decides to send the clause to legal counsel, who writes a narrower version that the playbook owner then approves as a new fallback. The agent logs the full sequence: the original text, the flag, the escalation, counsel's wording, the approval and the date. The next time a similar indemnity appears, the agent can point to the approved fallback, and the reviewer still decides whether it fits the deal.

Protect the review from untrusted text and excessive access

Contracts are written by outside parties, and they can contain sentences that look like instructions. A clause or an attached schedule might say that a reviewer has already approved something, or ask the reader to disregard earlier terms. The [OWASP guidance on prompt injection](https://cheatsheetseries.owasp.org/cheatsheets/LLM_Prompt_Injection_Prevention_Cheat_Sheet.html) describes why models can be steered by text inside the data they process. The control is structural: the agent treats document text as material to analyze, its instructions come only from the playbook and the workflow configuration, and it has no authority to approve or send anything.

Access should follow the same logic. The agent needs read access to the incoming contract folder and write access to a draft folder. It does not need permission to send email, change the playbook or delete records. The [OWASP authorization guidance](https://cheatsheetseries.owasp.org/cheatsheets/Authorization_Cheat_Sheet.html) is a useful checklist for confirming that each permission is limited to what the task requires. Review those permissions on a fixed schedule, and whenever the workflow changes. Approval rules for who can release a redline are covered in more detail in AI approval workflow routing.

How Be Human runs this as a managed service

Be Human designs and operates this kind of workflow as a managed service. A first engagement defines one useful role for the agent, the contract type it covers, the memory and tools it needs, the playbook fields, the approval boundaries and an observable success criterion, such as the share of flags a reviewer accepts without edits. Managed operations then include monitoring of flag quality, recurring evaluations against a set of past contracts, permission reviews, incident response when a flag is wrong in a way that matters, and controlled changes to the playbook that the owner approves. The service is remote and available in English and Portuguese.

Where to start

Most teams do not need to automate their whole contract process at once. A practical starting point is the contract type that arrives most often and causes the most back-and-forth, with a playbook that a reviewer can check in an afternoon. If you want to find the first contract task worth handing to an agent, take the free Be Human AI diagnostic.

Frequently asked questions

Can an AI agent approve a contract on our behalf? No, and the workflow should be built so that it cannot. The agent reads the contract, flags clauses against the playbook and drafts proposed redlines, but a qualified reviewer decides whether each change is acceptable. The agent has no permission to send, sign or accept a position, and every release passes through a named person.

Which clauses should the agent flag first? Start with the clauses that carry the most financial or legal exposure and that your team already negotiates the same way each time. Liability caps, indemnities, payment terms, automatic renewal and governing law are common choices. Adding more clause families later is easier once the first ones produce flags that reviewers trust.

Do we still need a lawyer if the agent drafts the redlines? Usually yes, at least for escalated clauses and for the playbook itself. The agent speeds up reading and drafting, but the decision to accept a new position, and the wording of any new fallback, should be approved by someone with legal authority in your organization. The playbook owner can be a lawyer, a senior operations leader or a contract manager, depending on how your company allocates that responsibility.

Does this workflow work for contracts written in Portuguese? It can, provided the playbook is written in the language of the contracts it covers and the reviewer reads that language fluently. Clause positions should be expressed as exact wording in each language, not translated loosely, because a small change in a Portuguese liability or indemnity clause can alter its effect. Be Human delivers this kind of work in English and Portuguese, and the playbook is the place where language choices are made explicit.

Your next step

See where an AI agent fits in your company first.

Take the free Be Human AI diagnostic. A few questions about your work show which task to hand to an agent first, what it needs to know and where a person approves.

Be Human editorial guidance. Examples are illustrative unless explicitly attributed. Sources provide background; implementation choices depend on your workflow.

Less busywork. More room for you.

Bring us the work you wish you had time for.

Book a call to try a personalized AI agent free for 7 days ↗Or take the free AI diagnostic →